dukie564

i advise against firestone or pepboys or general tire/oil change shops. A real mechanics shop will not charge a flat rate for those services typically - it'll be an hourly rate to do everything at once. Those tests shouldn't take more than an hour or two to complete at a good shop.

mikefrost

I grew up right outside of annapolis I know a couple of great mechanics in your area that would be happy to help you out and will not BS you or try to rip you off

MASCOTT

The shop I'm going too charges by the hour and the mechanic figured no more than 1 1/2 to do the diagnosis.

MASCOTT

Thank you. I found a shop that will do the diagnosis and the first thing the mechanic said was " why would anyone say replace the engine w/o first making sure that it was the engine?" When he said this, I knew this was the right place to take it :-).

dukie564

perfect - sounds like a winner to me

for future reference which shop was it?

MASCOTT

It was A.Arundel Auto which is about 3 minutes drive from where I live. I will post the findings as soon as I know something on Monday

tjwalker

Good luck and keep us posted. A proper diagnosis is critical here......

MASCOTT

Well the diagnosis is replace the engine. The sound is coming from the inside of the engine and there is no repair. Anybody know where I can get an engine? and install? Looks like I'm down, but I'm not out........I'll ride again

dukie564

well yea...we knew it was coming from inside the engine...

ask for the results of the compression test and post them here. Did he take the valve cover off and inspect the head?

MASCOTT

So much for my recommendation about this shop. They will not do compression test because it's in lower part of engine and is not a compression problem, they will not remove valve to inspect head because they feel it's a waste of time. I'm not a cussing woman but I'm about too. He did mention a bearing, but that was all. They just listened to the noise and hooked it up to get codes. I could have went to Amoco and had them do the same darn thing for free.

CAN SOMEBODY THAT KNOWS JEEPS, HAS A SHOP OR GARAGE.....PLEASE HELP ME !!!! I definitely don't have $1600 for a motor

dukie564

excuse me, but they need to do what you asked them to do, regardless of whether they feel like doing it. If they didn't do what you asked them to do, then they don't deserve to be paid.

mikefrost

I saw a few 4.0's on craigslist this morning and I can check to see what they have at Brandywine when I go there tomorrow

MASCOTT

OMG, I can't freakin believe this . They charge me $70 to tell me the engine has an internal knock (DUH) and then give me codes (1) po 303 misfire cylinder 3 (DUH AGAIN, I TOLD THEM ABOUT THAT ALREADY) (2) po 405 some kinda leak, .............

mikefrost

http://washingtondc.craigslist.org/n...850126644.html

http://washingtondc.craigslist.org/n...836988202.html

mikefrost

I'd be pretty pissed too