computer keeps reading o2 sensor. swapped out twice. rough idle getting worst. help.
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2022
Location: New York
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
Year: 2000
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0 6L
computer keeps reading o2 sensor. swapped out twice. rough idle getting worst. help.
ok so my CEL came on and the car was running fine until it wasn't. started with a light rough idle but the problem got worst. the computer gave me o2 sensor so we swapped it out. 2 weeks later boom CEL o2 sensor. swapped again. now we also replace the computer, still, o2 sensor CEL. what the heck is going on. someone help me. is the problem something that can be messing up the o2 sensor ?
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2020
Location: Prescott, AZ
Posts: 614
Received 201 Likes
on
156 Posts
Year: 1988
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0
Codes don't always mean that the sensor is bad. They just mean the computer can't understand something related to that code. E.g. an exhaust leak could let enough oxygen in to the exhaust to pin the O2 reading lean for a long enough time for the computer to set an O2 sensor related code.
There are many things that can break to set a code for any particular sensor. The code is just to get you started in the right direction. From there you have to gather your own data and use knowledge of the theory of operation of internal combustion engines to figure out what is acutally wrong.
We can help out with the knowledge part, but we can't get the data.
Since you've replaced the sensor many times and also the computer we can guess that those are not the problem and something else is causing this code. It was already stated in another thread that you should be checking for a wiring fault. Skipping that step and continuing to parts swap will just result in wasted money, wasted time, and frustration.
There are many things that can break to set a code for any particular sensor. The code is just to get you started in the right direction. From there you have to gather your own data and use knowledge of the theory of operation of internal combustion engines to figure out what is acutally wrong.
We can help out with the knowledge part, but we can't get the data.
Since you've replaced the sensor many times and also the computer we can guess that those are not the problem and something else is causing this code. It was already stated in another thread that you should be checking for a wiring fault. Skipping that step and continuing to parts swap will just result in wasted money, wasted time, and frustration.
#3
Senior Member
ok so my CEL came on and the car was running fine until it wasn't. started with a light rough idle but the problem got worst. the computer gave me o2 sensor so we swapped it out. 2 weeks later boom CEL o2 sensor. swapped again. now we also replace the computer, still, o2 sensor CEL. what the heck is going on. someone help me. is the problem something that can be messing up the o2 sensor ?
Edit :doublechaz types faster than I do...:-l
Last edited by exasemech; 01-18-2022 at 08:11 PM.
The following 2 users liked this post by exasemech:
Dceramic (06-07-2024),
doublechaz (01-19-2022)
#4
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2022
Location: New York
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
Year: 2000
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0 6L
hey guys sorry i posted this twice i didnt think this post went through andi guess i now opened my computer and listed it. with that being said im waiting on my test light and multimeter in the mail now to check the wiring harness that connects to the o2 sensor. appreciate you guys very much and i hope to diagnose this myself as it feels good to get things going especially because i bought this car with this sputter
The following users liked this post:
doublechaz (01-19-2022)
#5
CF Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2016
Posts: 3,539
Received 659 Likes
on
562 Posts
Year: 96
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0
a crap brand O2 sensor will throw a code in next to no time
use a good quality, or even a used one and see if that makes a difference
(after following the good recomendations of previous posters)
use a good quality, or even a used one and see if that makes a difference
(after following the good recomendations of previous posters)
#6
CF Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 7,412
Likes: 0
Received 1,557 Likes
on
1,197 Posts
Year: 2000
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Trending Topics
#8
CF Veteran
You can also get one of those freebie OBDII+ software apps and see what you sensors are doing. Might be cat time.
Typical O2 sensor graph:
That one's a sick sensor but you can also use it to figure out if you have a cat problem.
Typical O2 sensor graph:
That one's a sick sensor but you can also use it to figure out if you have a cat problem.
#10
CF Veteran
#11
Senior Member
To the OP
Given how many O2 sensors that have been put into that thing recently it's a little hard to believe they were all bad out of the box. Look at the sensor voltages you are getting on your scan tool; do they drop to zero-as in nothing? Or is there a voltage but the shift seems slow? If zero, another hint that maybe a wiring issue.
it is also possible something is contaminating the sensors. Need to be a lot of it to do it that fast but possible. Are you losing coolant that is showing up in the exhaust?
Note that I keep referring to "your" scan tool. If you don't have one run, don't walk, to a parts store and buy one: not a code reader but something that will give you live data. You can buy one for the price of an O2 sensor and if you are going to own a clapped out old vehicle you need one. Having a parts store read codes for you is not a solution.
ALSO reading all the various threads you have posted on this thing I realized it is a 2000 and you bought it in New Jersey. If it was originally sold in NJ it is likely a California version. (Check the emission label) They have 2 close coupled cats with an upstream and downstream O2 sensor on each...thats 4 total. The downstream sensors do nothing as far as the car running is concerned, they are for the OBD cat check
Do you have any idea which o2 sensors are showing bad? Again a scan tool will tell you. Which ones have been replaced?
Given how many O2 sensors that have been put into that thing recently it's a little hard to believe they were all bad out of the box. Look at the sensor voltages you are getting on your scan tool; do they drop to zero-as in nothing? Or is there a voltage but the shift seems slow? If zero, another hint that maybe a wiring issue.
it is also possible something is contaminating the sensors. Need to be a lot of it to do it that fast but possible. Are you losing coolant that is showing up in the exhaust?
Note that I keep referring to "your" scan tool. If you don't have one run, don't walk, to a parts store and buy one: not a code reader but something that will give you live data. You can buy one for the price of an O2 sensor and if you are going to own a clapped out old vehicle you need one. Having a parts store read codes for you is not a solution.
ALSO reading all the various threads you have posted on this thing I realized it is a 2000 and you bought it in New Jersey. If it was originally sold in NJ it is likely a California version. (Check the emission label) They have 2 close coupled cats with an upstream and downstream O2 sensor on each...thats 4 total. The downstream sensors do nothing as far as the car running is concerned, they are for the OBD cat check
Do you have any idea which o2 sensors are showing bad? Again a scan tool will tell you. Which ones have been replaced?
Last edited by exasemech; 01-19-2022 at 07:49 AM.
The following users liked this post:
doublechaz (01-19-2022)
#12
CF Veteran
disconnect both front or the one o2 sensor at the front connectors...computer now ignores o2 signals and goes to a preset standard calculation...if it smoothes out and runs better then you know there is nothing physically wrong but its a sensor/control issue
#14
Seasoned Member
Check the wiring harness
ok so my CEL came on and the car was running fine until it wasn't. started with a light rough idle but the problem got worst. the computer gave me o2 sensor so we swapped it out. 2 weeks later boom CEL o2 sensor. swapped again. now we also replace the computer, still, o2 sensor CEL. what the heck is going on. someone help me. is the problem something that can be messing up the o2 sensor ?