Rotella Oil
#18
Member
The misconceptions! You need oil Jesus.
Synthetic oil is NOT thinner. For example: 5w30 dino and 5w30 synthetic are the same viscosity. 10w40 dino and 10w40 synthetic are the same viscosity.
Moving on to what multi-viscosity ratings actually mean...
5w40 means that when COLD (0 deg C) its viscosity is that of a COLD 5 weight. When HOT (100 deg C) its viscosity is that of a HOT 40 weight.
Thicker is not inherently better. Long, technical story short, where oil viscosity is XwYY, X should be as low as possible. Even a cold 5 weight is still much thicker than a hot 40, so some people's belief that 0w__ and 5w__ oils are too thin for the 4.0 is false. YY can be 30 or 40, but 40 has been proven to not be inherently any better for the 4.0 than 30.
Now, you think that gear oil is thicker than motor oil because gear oil has ratings like 80w90. Gear oil isn't actually that much thicker. The ratings are so much different though because they are rated in a completely different way for different temps/circumstances. Regardless, you should NEVER use gear oil in the engine.
By running 15w40, your oil is needlessly thick when cold which could be producing increase wear during warm-up. Once it's hot, it's a 40 weight, and that is OK, but ultimately unnecessary. A 30 will protect just as well or perhaps even better and could provide a slight MPG boost.
Quoting myself from a thread on a different forum:
Synthetic oil is NOT thinner. For example: 5w30 dino and 5w30 synthetic are the same viscosity. 10w40 dino and 10w40 synthetic are the same viscosity.
Moving on to what multi-viscosity ratings actually mean...
5w40 means that when COLD (0 deg C) its viscosity is that of a COLD 5 weight. When HOT (100 deg C) its viscosity is that of a HOT 40 weight.
Thicker is not inherently better. Long, technical story short, where oil viscosity is XwYY, X should be as low as possible. Even a cold 5 weight is still much thicker than a hot 40, so some people's belief that 0w__ and 5w__ oils are too thin for the 4.0 is false. YY can be 30 or 40, but 40 has been proven to not be inherently any better for the 4.0 than 30.
Now, you think that gear oil is thicker than motor oil because gear oil has ratings like 80w90. Gear oil isn't actually that much thicker. The ratings are so much different though because they are rated in a completely different way for different temps/circumstances. Regardless, you should NEVER use gear oil in the engine.
By running 15w40, your oil is needlessly thick when cold which could be producing increase wear during warm-up. Once it's hot, it's a 40 weight, and that is OK, but ultimately unnecessary. A 30 will protect just as well or perhaps even better and could provide a slight MPG boost.
Quoting myself from a thread on a different forum:
Also just to confirm, if I run rotella 0w40 over 5w30 in my cherokee, the 40 weight won't be too thick?
Thanks
#19
Newbie
The misconceptions! You need oil Jesus.
Synthetic oil is NOT thinner. For example: 5w30 dino and 5w30 synthetic are the same viscosity. 10w40 dino and 10w40 synthetic are the same viscosity.
Moving on to what multi-viscosity ratings actually mean...
5w40 means that when COLD (0 deg C) its viscosity is that of a COLD 5 weight. When HOT (100 deg C) its viscosity is that of a HOT 40 weight.
Thicker is not inherently better. Long, technical story short, where oil viscosity is XwYY, X should be as low as possible. Even a cold 5 weight is still much thicker than a hot 40, so some people's belief that 0w__ and 5w__ oils are too thin for the 4.0 is false. YY can be 30 or 40, but 40 has been proven to not be inherently any better for the 4.0 than 30.
Now, you think that gear oil is thicker than motor oil because gear oil has ratings like 80w90. Gear oil isn't actually that much thicker. The ratings are so much different though because they are rated in a completely different way for different temps/circumstances. Regardless, you should NEVER use gear oil in the engine.
By running 15w40, your oil is needlessly thick when cold which could be producing increase wear during warm-up. Once it's hot, it's a 40 weight, and that is OK, but ultimately unnecessary. A 30 will protect just as well or perhaps even better and could provide a slight MPG boost.
Quoting myself from a thread on a different forum:
Synthetic oil is NOT thinner. For example: 5w30 dino and 5w30 synthetic are the same viscosity. 10w40 dino and 10w40 synthetic are the same viscosity.
Moving on to what multi-viscosity ratings actually mean...
5w40 means that when COLD (0 deg C) its viscosity is that of a COLD 5 weight. When HOT (100 deg C) its viscosity is that of a HOT 40 weight.
Thicker is not inherently better. Long, technical story short, where oil viscosity is XwYY, X should be as low as possible. Even a cold 5 weight is still much thicker than a hot 40, so some people's belief that 0w__ and 5w__ oils are too thin for the 4.0 is false. YY can be 30 or 40, but 40 has been proven to not be inherently any better for the 4.0 than 30.
Now, you think that gear oil is thicker than motor oil because gear oil has ratings like 80w90. Gear oil isn't actually that much thicker. The ratings are so much different though because they are rated in a completely different way for different temps/circumstances. Regardless, you should NEVER use gear oil in the engine.
By running 15w40, your oil is needlessly thick when cold which could be producing increase wear during warm-up. Once it's hot, it's a 40 weight, and that is OK, but ultimately unnecessary. A 30 will protect just as well or perhaps even better and could provide a slight MPG boost.
Quoting myself from a thread on a different forum:
The following users liked this post:
manamongtheruins (05-05-2021)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Greenwire6
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
213
12-19-2013 10:19 PM
GOTWAX
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
14
09-14-2012 08:31 PM
Wonka1981
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
12
07-13-2012 07:36 PM
stang23456
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
46
03-05-2012 03:27 PM
jacked_xj
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
22
01-12-2011 06:23 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)