Running towards the hot side
#1
Running towards the hot side
Hey guys, I have a 96 I'm having a little bit of a sporadic problem with. Memorial Day, I took it up and ran an old dirt road in the mountains. Had to pull over at one point, and let it cool off, temp was up in the red, and boiled a little over. Ran fine the rest of the day after that, although I did have to run the heat some along the trip to keep it in range. So, got it home, did a flush of the coolant system, replaced the thermostat, and radiator cap. Drove it for about 2 weeks straight with no problems. Then after a longer trip than normal, about 100 mile round trip, the water pump took a dump. After vacation, replaced the water pump, and fresh coolant. So I drove the thing for about a week or so, back and forth to work, around town, etc, etc, with no problems. Never touched the 210 mark. So last Friday, took about a 50 mile round trip, in some stop and go traffic, temp outside, hotter than a 4 balled tom cat, temp starts creeping up. I had to run the heat to get it to settle down. Most everything is new, with the exception of the fan clutch. Does this sound like my problem? I haven't tried spinning the fan with the vehicle hot, but with it cold, the fan wont make but about a 1/4 turn. Any advice where to look? Thanks in advance!
#2
CF Veteran
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 7,964
Likes: 957
From: Lost in the wilds of Virginia
Year: 1998 Classic (I'll get it running soon....) and 02 Grand
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0
- Your symptoms are a good match for a fan clutch.
- There is no reliable test to determine if it's working properly.
- A new fan clutch is cheap.
- Replacement is a pretty easy job.
I think all that adds up to, replace it and see how it goes!
#4
UPDATE
Hey guys it's been a while. So here is where I am at, and it's kinda weird to me. So after a couple of times of running in the "red" on my 96, I have noticed something. After replacing the usual coolant problem parts, electric fan, mechanical fan clutch, thermostat, radiator cap, water pump, and doing a flush this is what I have going on. Daily driving to and from work, hot days, air conditioning running, or even if I let it sit and idle, the temperature does fine, gets just shy of the 210 mark. But if I drive down the highway, speeds in excess of 60-65 mph, the temp starts to get a little past the 210 mark. Even if it's just a short trip on the highway. I don't get on the highway much with it, but it kinda takes out any road trips in the thing if it's hot outside. Anybody have a clue? Thanks in advance!
Last edited by HITDOGG; 06-18-2018 at 12:02 PM.
#5
Daily driving to and from work, hot days, air conditioning running, or even if I let it sit and idle, the temperature does fine, gets just shy of the 200 mark. But if I drive down the highway, speeds in excess of 60-65 mph, the temp starts to get a little past the 200 mark. Even if it's just a short trip on the highway. I don't get on the highway much with it, but it kinda takes out any road trips in the thing if it's hot outside. Anybody have a clue? Thanks in advance!
#6
I dont see an issue. The factory thermostat is 195. Normal operating temps are 210. Just shy of 200 or just a little over 200 is nothing to worry about. For what its worth, the last time i checked my 97 using the code reader, it read just shy of 200 when the gauge reads just shy of 210. This was just after a long drive.
Sorry, you must have read that and replied prior to my edit. I thought the temp reading straight up was 200 degrees. But it's 210. And it gets a little past that, and will boil over if I don't help it out. It just puzzles me that it only happens when I get on the highway. I can let it sit and idle, with the air conditioning on, and it won't over heat.
#7
CF Veteran
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 3,700
Likes: 236
From: Groton, MA
Year: 1995
Model: Cherokee(XJ)
Engine: I6 4.0L
Sorry, you must have read that and replied prior to my edit. I thought the temp reading straight up was 200 degrees. But it's 210. And it gets a little past that, and will boil over if I don't help it out. It just puzzles me that it only happens when I get on the highway. I can let it sit and idle, with the air conditioning on, and it won't over heat.
Have you done an oil analysis in the recent past?? If I had red-lined the temp as you've described then I'd be keeping a close eye out for block/head damage and an oil analysis is a great way to do that.
Trending Topics
#8
It shouldn't be boiling over at slightly over 210 - before I changed out my bad t-stat and fan clutch I'd drift into the 230-ish range with no boil-over at all. I'd wager that you have too much water in your coolant mixture. If it were me, I'd just replace the coolant with a name brand 50/50 premix and go from there.
Have you done an oil analysis in the recent past?? If I had red-lined the temp as you've described then I'd be keeping a close eye out for block/head damage and an oil analysis is a great way to do that.
Have you done an oil analysis in the recent past?? If I had red-lined the temp as you've described then I'd be keeping a close eye out for block/head damage and an oil analysis is a great way to do that.
I would agree with you on all of that. But this thing only gets over the 210 mark if I'm driving down the highway, at speeds over say 60 mph. I can let it sit and idle, on the hottest days, and the temp hand not get over 210.
And to clarify, it's only boiled over on me one time. If I have noticed it getting up in that range without and signs of leveling off, I'll usually turn the heat on. But again, I only have to worry about it driving on the highway. Back and forth to work, it does fine.
#9
CF Veteran
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 3,700
Likes: 236
From: Groton, MA
Year: 1995
Model: Cherokee(XJ)
Engine: I6 4.0L
I would agree with you on all of that. But this thing only gets over the 210 mark if I'm driving down the highway, at speeds over say 60 mph. I can let it sit and idle, on the hottest days, and the temp hand not get over 210.
And to clarify, it's only boiled over on me one time. If I have noticed it getting up in that range without and signs of leveling off, I'll usually turn the heat on. But again, I only have to worry about it driving on the highway. Back and forth to work, it does fine.
And to clarify, it's only boiled over on me one time. If I have noticed it getting up in that range without and signs of leveling off, I'll usually turn the heat on. But again, I only have to worry about it driving on the highway. Back and forth to work, it does fine.
T-stats can be picky, even out of the box, so it's not uncommon for one to not function in spec even when new.
Just a thought - of course.
#10
CF Veteran
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 3,700
Likes: 236
From: Groton, MA
Year: 1995
Model: Cherokee(XJ)
Engine: I6 4.0L
Also a very trusted member posted recently in another thread that a -little- over 210 is perfectly normal. If it's like 220+, I'd worry, if it's below that, you could try the Mopar t-stat if it bothers you.
#12
CF Veteran
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 3,700
Likes: 236
From: Groton, MA
Year: 1995
Model: Cherokee(XJ)
Engine: I6 4.0L
#14
I would agree with you on all of that. But this thing only gets over the 210 mark if I'm driving down the highway, at speeds over say 60 mph. I can let it sit and idle, on the hottest days, and the temp hand not get over 210.
And to clarify, it's only boiled over on me one time. If I have noticed it getting up in that range without and signs of leveling off, I'll usually turn the heat on. But again, I only have to worry about it driving on the highway. Back and forth to work, it does fine.
And to clarify, it's only boiled over on me one time. If I have noticed it getting up in that range without and signs of leveling off, I'll usually turn the heat on. But again, I only have to worry about it driving on the highway. Back and forth to work, it does fine.