Running towards the hot side
#16
CF Veteran
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 2,419
Likes: 250
From: Southern Texas (former AZ & Aus)
Year: 1999
Model: Cherokee(XJ)
Engine: I6 4.0L
I just got back from doing a 2,000 mile trip with my 99 XJ and even sitting in city traffic over Memorial Day weekend with no breeze at all, it was 90F+ out...I thought for sure she'd go **** up on me... but she never moved any higher than just a hair over the 210 mark. I was surprised to say the least... and went right back down to just under 210 after I got moving. And except for the towns/cities I went through, it was all highway... so I'd agree that I think the OP has something like that going on. Could be as easy as a t-stat change, but could very easily be the rad. Fortunately I've seen that those aren't too expensive to replace either.
#17
Thanks for all the input and replies! I reckon I'm gonna keep an eye on things for the time being. It hasn't really been that hot since I replaced the fan clutch. Maybe I was just over reacting when it got past the 210 mark the other day going down the highway. Maybe do some test runs to see. But a radiator might not be a bad investment anyway.
#18
These can be had for well under $100 if you shop around or search for A/Z coupons. Cheap insurance.
https://www.autozone.com/cooling-hea...107695_0_13752
https://www.autozone.com/cooling-hea...107695_0_13752
#19
Seasoned Member
Joined: Dec 2016
Posts: 391
Likes: 7
From: Lawrence ****ing Kansas
Year: 1997
Model: Cherokee
Engine: 4.0
Just like yours, my jeep overheats but only on the highway after 30-60 minutes of driving, depending on outside temps. I replaced the entire cooling system, aggressively flushed all the rust out, and then replaced the radiator again. Still didn't solve it. I did all the tests - compression, exhaust gases in coolant, cooling system pressure - none of them showed any problems. No obvious signs of a head gasket leak. I was dumbfounded.
I then send my oil sample into Blackstone labs and they found the coolant in the oil. I was in HGD (head gasket denial) for a few days until I finally accepted the truth, and I had the head off the next day. I took it to a machine shop yesterday and it was warped but the HG was not damage though you can see where the exhaust gases where getting past it from the discoloration.
In a few days I'll know for sure if it solves my problems. So right now it's just a theory, but my theory is that these engines are so badass they run great even with a warped head or blown head gasket. You'd never know until it starts to run a little hot. And when it does, you can, or at least I could, keep the temps under control by slowing down and turning on the heater. I did that well over a year, including a long trip to Colorado about a year ago. It did boil over a few times but it didn't seem to damage the engine at all. So most people might not ever detect it. There's many folks out there, myself included for a while, who say that these engines just like to run hot and the cooling system just isn't good enough. But maybe they have a tiny head gasket leak just like I did, and they'll never know it!
I'm not saying you for sure have a bad HG - the only thing worse than a bad HG is a misdiagnosed HG - but I think you should really check hard to make sure you're is not blown, including an oil analysis.
Last edited by mannydantyla; 06-19-2018 at 10:04 AM.
#20
Is the clutch fan shroud on it? If not then that'll bring the temp down a bit. Mine was getting just under the red on hot days and during long trips immediately after breaking my shroud and coolant was boiling but car want actually exactly overheating then I installed a new shroud and now its right about 210 all the time. Haven't had the problem in 3-4 weeks.